On 11 August, Atul Sati, Convenor of the Joshimath Bachao Sangharsh Samiti and member of the CPI(ML) State Committee, wrote to Uttarakhand Chief Minister Pushkar Dhami regarding the Dharali disaster, describing it as further proof of the government’s failure to ensure the safety of the people. On 5 August, a massive flash flood in Uttarkashi engulfed and destroyed the entire Dharali village, which lies on the pilgrim route to Gangotri Dham.

The letter noted that disasters linked to recurring calamities in the Himalayas have repeatedly demonstrated the vulnerability of the region, yet neither the state nor the central government has taken adequate preventive measures. The recent disaster in Dharali caused loss of life and property, and the government has failed to issue clear information on the number of casualties and the scale of damage.

Atul Sati pointed out that in March 2024, the Uttarakhand State Disaster Management Authority submitted a report to the National Disaster Management Authority confirming the risk of such a flood in the area and recommending preventive steps, yet no action was taken. He blamed negligence in early warning systems, disaster preparedness, rescue and relief measures.

The letter also raised concerns over inadequate rehabilitation and compensation arrangements for affected residents, urging the state government to act immediately to prevent further tragedies.

In the letter six demands were given to the Chief Minister:

1.  Immediate presentation of a detailed report on the Dharali disaster, with clear government statements on casualties and damage.
2. Announcement of a special permanent policy for disaster-prone areas, specifying rehabilitation locations in advance.
3. Compensation for losses in business and agriculture sectors, along with assessment of damage and provision of adequate compensation. An Uttarakhand-level committee should be formed to oversee post-disaster relief.
4. Deployment of adequate personnel for debris clearance to ensure proper rehabilitation before the monsoon ends.
5. Provision of disaster shelters and relief materials in advance in disaster-prone areas.
6. Establishment of at least one government relief camp in each affected area for a minimum of one month, providing food, essential items and necessities.

Atul Sati concluded by stating that the Dharali disaster once again highlights the urgent need for preventive and safety measures at the state level.